I don't know that I've ever read a book about someone named Dexter. Unlike Jack or Sam or John or James or Will, Dexter isn't a name that every male protagonist or deuteragonist goes by. And while I have dexterity (that's me being punny) at reading multiple books I once, I can tell you with great certainty that I have never simultaneously read two romances about two Dexters. Quite confusing.
Let's start with This Lullaby. It's the typical Sarah Dessen formula: smart girl with some sort of problem (pregnancy, weight issues, relationship troubles, abusive family, abusive boyfriend, can't ride a bike) meets swoon-worthy guy, romance ensues, and happy ending roll credits. It's a formula I don't necessarily like in large amounts, but every once in a while I get the itch. This time around it's Remy Starr, who goes through boyfriends like they're sticks of gum, and Dexter Jones, a dirt-poor, klutzy musician, who isn't Remy's type. At. All. Wink wink nudge nudge poke poke. I like this one. Not my favorite, but Sarah Dessen is always good.
Then there's One Day. It literally is about the same day, July fifteenth, across a span of twenty years. Advice: do not devour. This book was a hefty undertaking, at least for little old me. Perhaps it was the massive amount of time that the story spanned across, but I couldn't do it in one afternoon, or even a week. Like This Lullaby, it's a romantic story centered around Emily Morley, an aspiring writer, and Dexter Mayhew, who's aspiring to be something of course. It's not an easy relationship; they never are. A series of missed and taken opportunities outline their lives and weave their stories together. The only thing I disliked about this story was Dexter for, like, the first half of the book.
Two good books, two Dexters, and a recommendation that, if you haven't already, you read these in the summer, not fall-ish winter, like I just did.
So in the battle of the Dexters, who wins? I think I'll stick with clumsy musician Dexter. But if we're comparing books, I think I like One Day just a smidgen more.
In other news maybe it's just Anne Hathaway's accent or the Disney-style narration, but from just watching the trailer, this movie seems awesomely cheesy/horrid. Sorry Anne, I like you and all but the accent needs fixing, plus Emma is supposed to have red hair. Still, I foster an abnormal affection for the awesomely cheesy/horrid, so I'll probably watch it in a few weeks or months or whenever someone puts it on Youtube.
Update: Not pretending that I know anything about movies, but this one was so cute, especially toward the end.